Skip to content

(908) 354-1887

639 South Broad Street Elizabeth, NJ 07202

One half block in from Bayway Ave.  One and a half blocks in from US1&9

Great-Tasting Brick Oven Pizza in New Jersey

Chow Now
Menu Download PDF

Get our app!

Menu-Logo-Large

Baked To Order

6 Minutes - Soft Crust
7 Minutes - Light Golden
8 Minutes - Golden Crust

9 Minutes - Dark Golden Crust
10 Minutes - Brown/Black Crust

(Plain Sauce & Cheese)

Small

Large

XL

Round

$14.00

$19.00

$22.00

Sicilian

$20.00

$24.00

$28.00

1/2 or whole

Toppings

$4.00 each

Cheese

Meats

Additional Toppings

Fresh Mozzarella

Pecorino Romano

Ricotta

Truffle Parm

Extra Cheese

Anchovies

Chicken

Clams

Hams

Meatball

Pepperoni

Sausage

Artichoke

Bell Pepper

Eggplant

Fresh Garlic

Hot Banana Pepper

Jalapeno

Mushroom

Olives

Onions

Pineapple

San Marzano's Tomatoes

Sesame Crust

Spinach

BAKED TO ORDER

6 Minutes - Soft Crust
7 Minutes - Light Golden
8 Minutes - Golden Crust
9 Minutes - Dark Golden Crust
10 Minutes - Brown/Black Crust

Small
(Plain Sauce & Cheese)
ROUND - $14.00
SICILIAN - $20.00

Large
(Plain Sauce & Cheese)
ROUND - $19.00
SICILIAN - $24.00

XL
(Plain Sauce & Cheese)
ROUND - $22.00
SICILIAN - $28.00

TOPPINGS

1/2 OR WHOLE

$4.00 EACH

Cheese

Fresh Mozzarella

Pecorino Romano

Ricotta

Truffle Parm

Extra Cheese

Meats

Anchovies

Chicken

Clams

Hams

Meatball

Pepperoni

Sausage

Other

Artichoke

Bell Pepper

Eggplant

Fresh Garlic

Hot Banana Pepper

Jalapeno

Mushroom

Olives

Onions

Pineapple

San Marzano's Tomatoes

Sesame Crust

Spinach

1940 Genuine Tomato Pie

No Cheese, Only Sauce, Any Size
$ 18.00

1948 Style Tomato Pie with Grated Cheese

No Mozzarella
$ 19.00

1957 Style Pizza Extra Thin 14" Round

18" - $22.00
$ 15.00

1959 Style Large (Thick & Saucy) 14" Round

$ 19.00

1960 Style 16" Round Large

Less Cheese, More Sauce
$ 19.00

1964 Style 16"

Our Standard Pie, garnished with Extra Virgin Olive Oil & Paresan
$ 23.00

1967 Pop's Style 16" Round

Cheese goes on so you see some sauce
$ 19.00

1990 Style

Soft crust, "American Style", Large
$ 19.00

2011 San Marzano Tomatoes over the cheese ("Our Margarita") 16" Round

$ 23.00

2020 Style Pizza 16" Round

Fresh Mozzarella, Pecorino Romano Cheese & San Marzano Tomatoes
$ 28.00

White Pizza 12"

$ 18.00

FOCACCIA, ("Flat Garlic Bread") 16"

$ 18.00

White Pizza 16"

$ 24.00

Calzone

Ricotta Cheese ,Mozzarella, 1 Filling, enough for for 2
$ 18.00

Pan Pizza Deep Dish 12"

$ 20.00

Stromboli

Sauce Cheese, 1 Filling, Peppers & Onions Optional, Feeds 2-4
$ 27.00

Pan Pizza Deep Dish 16"

$ 24.00

Lasagna Pizza16" round

Ricotta, Mozzarella and Sauce, other sizes available
$ 25.00

Thin Pan Pie 16"

$ 24.00

Roman Style

Easy on the Sauce, Easy on the Cheese, the better to taste our Delicious Crust
$ 18.00

Italian Pizza Bread

$ 17.00

Brooklyn Style Pizza

Cheese goes on first
$ 29.00

Bread Sticks (Garlic Knots) 1 6 Fresh Made Regular or Garlic

$ 17.00

Mozzarella Sricks House Version (16)

$ 18.00

Zeppoli's with Powdered Sugar 21bs.

$ 18.00

GRANDMA PIE

Add San Marzano Tomato & Pecorino Romano Cheese
$ 36

Garlic Bread

Add Cheese +$2
$ 12.00

Pepperoni Mozzarella Cheese Bread

$ 10

Sausage Mozzarella Cheese Bread

$ 10

Hot Subs

18"........................ $25.00

Chicken
Meatball
Eggplant
Sausage

Tables available for our customers as the Past Time Tavern
520 Bayway Ave

Scroll To Top